2503 Fogarty Avenue, Key West, FL 33040

New Listing

$1,350,000

Front Unit 2 bedroom 1 bath, new kitchen

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 5 Baths: 3 Square Footage: 1,950 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 5,000 Status: Active

Current Price: $1,350,000 List Date: 11/09/2026 Last Modified: 11/09/2026

Overview

Description

Tropical Living Meets Investment Opportunity in the Heart of Key West! Welcome to 2503 Fogarty Avenue, a charming income producing multi unit property tucked behind a classic white picket fence. Offering a total of 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms across two separate residences, this versatile property combines modern comforts, tropical outdoor living and exceptional investment potential. The front residence features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, beginning with a covered front porch perfect for morning coffee or relaxing. Inside high ceilings create a bright airy atmosphere while the updated kitchen features granite countertops, white cabinetry and a gas range. Additional conveniences include an in unit washer and dryer, along with separate water and electric meters. Privately situated at the rear of the property, the spacious 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom residence is a true tropical retreat. Step outside into your own lush backyard oasis where mature mango and banana trees surround a lar ... (Read more)

Listing Details MLS# 622007

Location, Tax & Legal

Street #: 2503
Street Name: Fogarty
Street Suffix: Avenue
Key/Island: Key West
State/Province: FL
Zip Code: 33040
County: Monroe
Subdivision: Key West Realty Cos Sub (3.0)
Area: 03 - Key West
KW Neighborhood: Midtown East
City: KEY WEST
Mile Marker: 3
Marathon Neighborhood: N/A
Side: Median
Alternate Key #: 1051128
Parcel #: 00050520000000
Zoning: SF - Single Family
Deed Restrictions: Unknown
Legal: Kw Kw Realty Cos First Sub Pb1-43 Lot 2 Sqr 43 Tr 21 Or265-379/80 Or558-861 Or720-472D/C Or720-464/65 Or763-1245 Or976-2
Taxes: 8468.1
Tax Year: 2025
Pub Sewer HkUp: Yes

Contract Information

Listing Board: Key West Association

General Property Description

Realtor.COM Type: Multi-family
Style: Multi-Units
Waterfront: No
Pool: Yes
Year Built: 1943
Total Units: 2
Lot SqFt: 5000
Living Apx SqFt: 1950
SqFt Source: Tax Records
Total Bedrooms: 5
Full Baths: 3
Total Baths: 3
Rentals Allowed: With Restrictions
Control Depth: 0

Association Info

Mandatory Home Owners Asc: No
1st Right of Refusal: No
Association Fee $: 0

License Info

# of City License: 2

More Information

Building Style

Above Flood: Unknown

Remarks & Misc

Remarks – Consumer: Tropical Living Meets Investment Opportunity in the Heart of Key West! Welcome to 2503 Fogarty Avenue, a charming income producing multi unit property tucked behind a classic white picket fence. Offering a total of 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms across two separate residences, this versatile property combines modern comforts, tropical outdoor living and exceptional investment potential. The front residence features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, beginning with a covered front porch perfect for morning coffee or relaxing. Inside high ceilings create a bright airy atmosphere while the updated kitchen features granite countertops, white cabinetry and a gas range. Additional conveniences include an in unit washer and dryer, along with separate water and electric meters. Privately situated at the rear of the property, the spacious 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom residence is a true tropical retreat. Step outside into your own lush backyard oasis where mature mango and banana trees surround a large in ground concrete swimming pool. A generous lanai provides the perfect setting for alfresco dining, entertaining guests, or simply enjoying the Key West lifestyle. This residence also features a full kitchen, washer and dryer, and impact-resistant windows and doors. Adding even more versatility is a newly renovated bonus unit along the side of the home, complete with a private teak outdoor patio, an inviting space offering additional flexibility and privacy. Whether you're looking to expand your investment portfolio, enjoy multigenerational living or occupy one residence while generating rental income from the others, 2503 Fogarty Avenue offers an outstanding opportunity to own an exceptional Key West property!

Fee Includes

None: Yes

Dockage

None: Yes

Tax Exemptions

None: Yes

Appliances

Dishwasher: Yes
Dryer: Yes
Microwave: Yes
Oven: Yes
Range: Yes
Refrigerator: Yes
Washer: Yes

Pets

Pets Allowed: Yes

Cooling

Ceiling Fans(s): Yes
Central Air: Yes

Waterfront

None: Yes

Waterview

No Waterview: Yes

Floor

Tile: Yes

Interior Features

Granite Counter Top: Yes

Property Condition

Updated/Remodeled: Yes

Windows/Doors

Impact Rstnce Doors: Yes
Impact Rstnce Window: Yes

Construction

Frame: Yes

Land Size

Less Than 1/4 Acre: Yes

Furnished

Unfurnished: Yes

Terms

Cash: Yes
Conventional: Yes

Utilities

FKAA: Yes
Municipal Sewer: Yes

Porch/Balcony

Deck: Yes
Open Porch/Balcony: Yes

Exterior Features

Fruit Tree(s): Yes
Lanai: Yes
Lighting: Yes
Outdoor Shower: Yes
Rain Gutters: Yes

Pool Info

In Ground: Yes
Concrete: Yes

Roof

Metal Roof: Yes

Property Features

Fee Includes: None Tax Exemptions: None Waterfront: None Waterview: No Waterview Dockage: None Property Condition: Updated/Remodeled Furnished: Unfurnished Cooling: Ceiling Fans(s); Central Air Utilities: FKAA; Municipal Sewer Interior Features: Granite Counter Top Appliances: Dishwasher; Dryer; Microwave; Oven; Range; Refrigerator; Washer Exterior Features: Fruit Tree(s); Lanai; Lighting; Outdoor Shower; Rain Gutters Pool Info: In Ground; Concrete Construction: Frame Floor: Tile Roof: Metal Roof Pets: Pets Allowed Land Size: Less Than 1/4 Acre Terms: Cash; Conventional

Listing Office: Preferred Properties (KW)

Last Updated: November - 09 - 2026

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Florida Keys MLS, Inc. Information provided is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commeral use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. IDX data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Search powered by FBS Products